The scientific argument for mastering one thing at a time
- sarah-jane956
- Dec 28, 2025
- 7 min read
Can't see this message? View in browser |
The scientific argument for mastering one thing at a time 
Meet Linda. She is 53, works in marketing, and on January 1st, 2026, she woke up with a plan. This was going to be her year. She would join the gym. Start meal prepping. Drink more water. Walk 10,000 steps daily. Cut back on wine. Get more sleep. Maybe try meditation.
By January 18th, she had not been to the gym in five days. The meal prep containers sat unused in the cupboard. And that meditation app was still on the free trial.
Linda is not lazy. She is not lacking willpower. She simply fell into the same trap that derails most of us: trying to change everything at once.
THE COMEDIAN WHO BECAME A PRODUCTIVITY EXPERT
Jerry Seinfeld, before he became one of the most successful comedians in history, had a problem. He wanted to become a better comic, but like most aspiring performers, he struggled with consistency. He wrote jokes sporadically when inspiration struck, when he felt motivated, when he had time.
Then he made one simple decision: write jokes every single day. That was it. Not write brilliant material. Not develop a tight five-minute set. Just write something funny every day.
He bought a wall calendar and put a big red X through each day he wrote. After a few days, he had a chain of Xs. His only job became not breaking the chain.
That single habit of writing daily became the foundation of his career. Not because every day produced gold, but because consistency itself created the conditions for excellence. Everything else in his comedy career was built on that one disciplined practice.
Here is what the research tells us and what I have observed working with hundreds of people over nearly six years: the fastest way to change your entire life is to stop trying to change your entire life all at once.
THE SCIENCE OF ONE THING
Behavioral psychologists have discovered something fascinating about habit formation. When people make a specific plan stating exactly when, where, and how they will perform a new behavior, they become two to three times more likely to follow through.
Researchers call these implementation intentions. Instead of saying I will exercise more, you say I will strength train every Tuesday and Thursday at 9am. Instead of I will write more, you say I will write for 30 minutes every morning at 6am at my kitchen table.
The difference is dramatic. But here is the catch that changes everything. This only works when you focus on one habit at a time.
Study after study confirms it. People who try to build multiple habits simultaneously show less commitment and lower success rates than those who concentrate on a single goal. When you split your focus, you split your chances of success.
WHY YOUR BRAIN NEEDS REPETITION AND TIME
Think about the first time you drove a car. You had to consciously think about every action. Check the mirror. Signal. Check the blind spot. Turn the wheel. Accelerate gently. It was exhausting.
Now you probably drive while having a conversation, listening to a podcast, planning your day. The behavior became automatic.
Researchers call this automaticity, the ability to perform an action without deliberate thought. And here is what matters for those of us trying to build healthier lives: automaticity only develops through repetition.
Research shows the average habit takes about 66 days of consistent practice to become automatic. Some habits take less time. Others take more. The point is not the exact number. The point is understanding that real change requires months, not days.
This is why January resolutions typically fail by February. We have not given our new behaviors enough repetition to become automatic before piling on the next change.
THE WRITER WHO LOST 70 POUNDS BY IGNORING WEIGHT LOSS
Stephen Guise wrote about his transformation in his book Mini Habits. He was overweight, sedentary, and overwhelmed by the idea of getting fit. Every attempt at dramatic change had failed.
So he tried something radical. His only goal was to do one push-up per day. Just one.
One push-up will not transform anyone’s body. But that was not the point. The point was to show up consistently and make the behavior automatic. Most days, after doing his one required push-up, he did more. But the commitment was only to one.
That single, almost embarrassingly small habit became the foundation. Once showing up for movement became automatic, he gradually built on it. Eventually, he lost 70 pounds and developed a consistent exercise practice, but only because he started with something so simple he could not fail.
The transformation did not come from the one push-up. It came from proving to himself, day after day, that he could be someone who shows up.
WHAT THIS LOOKS LIKE IN REAL LIFE
I think about Michael, one of our clients who started training at 62. He had retired the year before and found himself drifting. Sleeping in. Skipping meals. Feeling disconnected. His wife suggested he might be depressed. He was not sure, but he knew he felt aimless.
When we first talked, he wanted to fix everything. Get stronger. Lose the retirement weight. Organize his days. Reconnect with old hobbies. Improve his diet. Maybe learn guitar.
What if we just focused on showing up Tuesday and Thursday mornings, I suggested. That is it. We build from there.
For the first eight weeks, that was his only commitment. He did not track his nutrition. He did not add extra workouts. He just came in twice a week and trained.
Around week ten, something shifted. He stopped debating whether he felt like coming. It was simply what he did on Tuesday and Thursday mornings. The behavior had become automatic.
What surprised him was how that structure carried into other parts of his life. He started going to bed earlier on Monday and Wednesday nights so he would feel good for training. He began eating breakfast because he noticed he felt better during sessions. Within six months, he had rebuilt a sense of routine and purpose, not through willpower, but through one foundational habit that everything else organized around.
I think the training saved my retirement, he told me recently. Not because of the exercise itself, but because it gave me a reason to show up for my life again.
THE NURSE WHO FINALLY STARTED READING AGAIN
Then there is Catherine, 49, a nurse who came to me frustrated about something that had nothing to do with fitness. She used to love reading but had not finished a book in three years. Her bedside table was stacked with half-read novels.
She had tried everything. Book clubs. Ambitious reading lists. Apps that tracked pages. All of it made things worse.
During a conversation about habit building for her training, she mentioned this frustration. I just miss being someone who reads, she said.
What if you read for five minutes before bed, I suggested. That is it.
She was skeptical. Five minutes seemed pointless.
But she tried it. Five minutes was easy enough that she never skipped. Some nights she only read five minutes. Most nights she kept going. The friction was never the reading. It was opening the book.
Eight months later, she had read seventeen books. The habit became automatic around week six. Now she does not think about it. She just reads before bed.
I feel like myself again, she said. I did not realize how much I had lost that part of my identity.
THE POWER OF SEQUENTIAL CHANGE
What Michael and Catherine discovered and what the research confirms is that sustainable change happens sequentially, not simultaneously.
When you master one habit and it becomes automatic, it frees up mental energy and decision-making capacity. That is when you are ready to add the next thing.
If you successfully build one new habit every three months, you will have four new automatic behaviors by the end of 2026. If you try to build four habits at once and burn out by February, you will have zero.
Slow and sequential beats fast and frantic every time.
YOUR ONE THING FOR 2026
As we step into the new year, resist the urge to overhaul everything. Instead, ask yourself what is the one habit that, if mastered, would make the biggest difference in your life.
Make your plan specific.
When will you do it Where will it happen How exactly will you execute it
Write it down. Remove friction. Make it almost too easy.
Focus exclusively on this habit for the next 60 to 90 days. Give your brain time to make it automatic. When it becomes something you do without debate, then and only then add the next habit.
REAL CHANGE DOES NOT REQUIRE PERFECTION
Linda changed her approach. Instead of trying to transform everything in January, she chose one thing: strength training twice a week.
She has been consistent for eleven months now. Her knees do not hurt anymore. She is stronger. And other changes followed naturally. Better sleep. Better energy. Small improvements to how she eats.
That is how real change works. Not through massive overhauls, but through one sustainable habit that becomes the foundation for everything else.
HOW THIS APPLIES TO TRAINING
When it comes to health and fitness, the one habit that creates the biggest downstream impact is consistency. And in practice, consistency breaks down far more often because of logistics than motivation.
That is one of the reasons we expanded Beyond Fitness to include In-Home Personal Training.
For some people, coming to the studio twice a week works beautifully. For others, particularly busy professionals, couples, or anyone juggling demanding schedules, removing the commute and scheduling friction is what finally allows training to become automatic.
The environment matters less than the repeatability. When training fits seamlessly into your life, it becomes something you simply do, not something you constantly renegotiate with yourself.
If you would like to learn more about Beyond Fitness In-Home Personal Training and who it is designed for, you can read more here.
Sarah-Jane Beyond Fitness Learn more about In-Home Personal Training Share on social This email was created with Wix. Discover More
|
Comments